This recipe is my favorite thing to pack for lunch. It’s a simple recipe, only requiring 3 different ingredients and only takes 5 minutes to prepare so you can be on roll! Not to mention it uses my favorite food, I can’t believe it’s not butter!
Ingredients:
- 2 & 1/2 cups of butter
- 5 cups of I can’t believe it’s not butter
- 6 slices rye bread
First things first, grab a frying pan and throw the 1/2 cup of regular butter on it. Turn up the heat on your stove to medium to ensure the butter starts to melt. Once your butter is melted in the pan, go ahead and throw a couple slices of rye bread in there. The butter will begin to soak into the bread. Don’t be afraid if it starts to sizzle, this is normal. If the sizzling becomes overly aggressive, go ahead and adjust the heat on your stove… again don’t worry.
The next step is kind of tricky, you need to grab another piece of bread and lather it up with I can’t believe it’s not butter. During this step you need to be absolutely sure you spread it evenly so the butter flavors do not intermingle. Once you have evenly spread the butter, you can go ahead and throw these pieces on top of the ones soaking in the pan. Once these are added, you can flip the whole sandwich together.
Finally, take any leftover butter you have and go ahead pour it over your sandwich. This stage acts as a decadent sauce for your sandwich. I prefer my sandwich to be dripping in butter but obviously this stage is up to your taste


